Rethinking the ‘gay best friend’ | Friendship

Ryan and I met working behind the tills in HMV Cork within the winter of 2009. We bonded immediately, and as we’re each pure romantics, started the method of myth-making in our friendship whereas it was nonetheless slippery from start. We moved in collectively rapidly. We started writing a sitcom based mostly on our lives, then obtained stoned and paranoid about being sued by former co-workers once we grew to become well-known. We left lengthy Fb posts on one another’s partitions, quoting the issues we stated to 1 one other, terrified that our specialness and our closeness wouldn’t be observed or rewarded by the broader world. We needed them to say: you two actually have one thing right here.

We have been 19, and we have been unbearable. However there was a number of that type of factor round. Brilliant younger girls and their even brighter homosexual buddies have been burning up our screens. There was Will & Grace, after all, and there was Stanford Blatch from Intercourse and The Metropolis. There was Stanley Tucci’s Nigel in The Satan Wears Prada, and Damian in Imply Ladies, and Rupert Everett’s George in My Greatest Good friend’s Marriage ceremony. We opened Phrase paperwork, centre-aligned the textual content and transcribed ourselves.

Unbearable as we have been, it wasn’t incorrect of us to consider our dynamic, the info of it anyway, as TV-ready. You needed to be fast and younger and pop-culture obsessed. We have been these issues. You needed to be adventure-ready, barely fucked-up, and we have been that, too. We had no life experiences and no tasks and so crammed that chasm with plot. Like Associates episodes, we considered every day of our life collectively as The One With. The One With The Failed Oscars Get together. The One The place We Performed Conceal and Search On The Roof. The One The place Every Jilted Our One Evening Stands In Order To Eat A Lasagne In An Italian Restaurant at Eleven In The Morning.

Inevitably, the sitcom thought tailed off, and so did the dwelling collectively. Ryan did a masters diploma in Wales, and I moved to London in 2011. I grew to become a author and whereas the friendship maintained itself at varied distances, it didn’t happen to me to write down about Ryan or our relationship once more. It wasn’t as if we had no adventures, no plot. If something, the foremost actions of our lives nonetheless appeared to attract us again collectively. Ryan moved to London in March 2014; I broke up with my live-in boyfriend in April. Ryan got here and crammed a black cab with my issues – I nonetheless didn’t have very many issues – and he took me to his home.

“Thanks for coming to get me,” I stated, an Anglepoise lamp teetering on my lap at the back of the cab.

“I’ll at all times come to get you,” he replied and, since then, it’s turn out to be an odd mantra of our friendship. He stated it to me final Sunday, when he picked me up for brunch. A name and response, a tune lyric that I at all times begin and he at all times finishes.

Caroline O’Donoghue and Ryan Farrell, arm in arm
Two’s firm: Ryan and Caroline. {Photograph}: David Titlow/The Observer

That day has been a chicken-or-egg query in my head ever since. I do know that the boyfriend and I broke up for good causes. However did I time the break as much as go along with Ryan’s arrival? Was it only a coincidence? I had no household within the nation earlier than Ryan emigrated, nobody who would take care of me if I wanted it. So I delay needing something till he confirmed up, after which I wanted all the things.

The years handed and a cultural resistance grew up round “the homosexual greatest good friend”. A way of disgust round Will & Grace, round Stanford Blatch. As a lot as these characters supplied vitality and verve to in any other case by-the-book motion pictures, the constraints of the homosexual greatest good friend grew to become a topic of cultural critique. Who have been these homophobic caricatures, and why have been they so in all places?

They supplied the heroine with empathy and entry to a extremely related underworld of tradition, media and no matter else she may want. However their sexuality, their personal lives, their needs and needs are unimportant. They dissolve as quickly because the heroine leaves the room, or places the cellphone down.

As Elliot Web page writes in his new memoir, Web pageboy, “Hollywood is constructed on leveraging queerness. Tucking it away when wanted, pulling it out when helpful, whereas patting themselves on the again.”

The homosexual greatest good friend was pretty criticised for being an instance of each the tuck and pull of queer tradition in mainstream media. He couldn’t win: to conservative viewers, he was an excessive amount of, and to liberal ones, not sufficient.

Caroline and Ryan, with Caroline’s head on Ryan’s shoulder
‘We discovered ourselves in a tattoo parlour, getting matching True Romance tattoos’: Caroline, with Ryan. {Photograph}: David Titlow/The Observer

Whereas a lot was written within the intervening years about what this inventory character couldn’t give us, there was nearly nothing written about what he may. He remained a standby of the sitcom and the romcom, typically offering the com in every. However he was just about invisible in literary fiction, the place I used to be making an attempt to make a reputation for myself.

Friendship, we’ve determined, is a dependable topic for literary exploration. Feminine friendship greater than something. From Elena Ferrante’s Neapolitan novels to Zadie Smith’s Swing Time, and The Pleasure Luck Membership to Fried Inexperienced Tomatoes, there have at all times been an excessive amount of phrases put aside for girls agonising about their relationships with different girls. Ladies are those studying the overwhelming majority of novels on this planet, in spite of everything, and it is sensible that they’d wish to examine their relationships with each other.

And but in all of the numerous literary friendship tales, the connection between homosexual males and straight girls feels barely touched. It’s an entertaining topic sufficient for comedy, however not for exploration inside drama. In our resistance to the homosexual greatest good friend as a trope, now we have left out analysing the nuances of the dynamic to start with. We’ve got determined that this explicit type of relationship is low-rent, and type of cheesy. There is not going to be a trio of Elena Ferrante novels about it.

I’ve been writing novels for six years, and studying them for much longer. I’ve realized by now that when there may be an absence of tales a few given topic, it’s both as a result of it lacks stakes or it lacks an viewers. The viewers query is a no brainer. Each girl and homosexual man I do know has a relationship of their lives that could be a bit like this. Thanks for coming to get me/I’ll at all times come to get you.

So let’s discuss stakes. Tales about platonic friendship are at all times cautious on this topic, just because romantic relationships have the stakes inbuilt. Will they are saying, “I really like you”? Will he suggest? Will they each present as much as the marriage and, inevitably, will they each keep devoted? Friendship tales need to be extra artistic. There aren’t any flashy ceremonies constructed into friendship and you’ll have as many buddies as you want, so constancy isn’t a wrestle.

Caroline and Ryan sitting outside at a table having drinks and laughing
‘We argued over which of us was the Geena Davis, unhealthy Sandy, Dolly Parton’. {Photograph}: David Titlow/The Observer

And but once I look at my and Ryan’s relationship, I can see that from its very beginnings, the stakes have been huge. Formally talking, Ryan was straight. He existed, in 2009, in what I consider as a really Schrödinger’s Cat downside of queerness. It was too harmful for him to come back out and so we existed in a suspended realm of each realizing and never realizing – defending his proper to be straight proper now if he wanted to be straight proper now, but in addition leaving room for the inevitable popping out, later. And whereas it was understood that we might preserve a mutual delusion of his straightness, we spent all of our spare time having the gayest conversations conceivable.

Maybe it was this foundational dishonesty that led to the interior world of personal jokes and fantasy that rapidly grew round us. We weren’t dowdy college students in retail, however darling chat present hosts, Southern belles, previous film stars. We watched Thelma & Louise, The Greatest Little Whorehouse in Texas, Hairspray, Grease, and argued about which one among us was the Geena Davis, which was the Dolly Parton, which the Dangerous Sandy.

There’s one thing, I feel, within the specifics of the homosexual man/straight girl dynamic that lends itself to this sort of playtime. Possibly the truth that straight girls and homosexual males, for various causes, need to current such a wide range of masks to the world. She, if she needs a boyfriend, has to faucet into the deep female nicely of being each effortlessly stunning and cheerfully lowkey. If she needs to be beloved by different girls, she should method them with humility and a low profile. “If there are three little ladies,” a good friend with daughters tells me, “two of them are speaking shit in regards to the third.”

For him, the stakes are increased. Significantly in 2009. The strain of passing is extra intense, and should you can’t go, then to be the type of homosexual one that is humorous and received’t attempt something bizarre. It’s exhausting. It was designed to be.

What’s extra alluring than somebody who needs to drop the droopy, gauzy veil of on a regular basis life with you, and as a substitute don the heightened, insane costume of Bette Davis and Joan Crawford in No matter Occurred to Child Jane?

“However you ARRRR in that chair, Blanche!”

Rupert Everett and Julia Roberts in My Best Friend’s Wedding.
In your aspect: Rupert Everett and Julia Roberts in My Greatest Good friend’s Marriage ceremony. {Photograph}: Tristar Footage/Allstar

Our home was a nature reserve for state-protected campness, and it wanted to be shielded from all the things that threatened it. A part of my 19-year-old self by no means needed Ryan to come back out in order that I may stick with it being the only receiver of his outsized specialness.

“So that you’re writing about your homosexual greatest good friend?” It’s February 2021 and, within the midst of late-pandemic melancholy, I’ve come again to the concept of writing about me and Ryan. That is my sixth novel and my first to commit the feminine author’s sin of identifiably utilizing my life to tell my fiction. It strikes me, once more, that there are issues that haven’t been stated about how homosexual males and straight girls relate. Instantly, I can see them in all places. The Sound of Music was on, once more, at Christmas. For the primary time I had little interest in Maria or Captain Von Trapp. I used to be trying on the Baroness and Max.

Baroness Elsa von Schraeder, you’ll keep in mind, has been the long-time lover of Captain Von Trapp and spends the whole movie strolling the high-wire act that the widower units out for her. She have to be the swish, stunning aristocrat he fell in love with in Vienna, however should additionally morph on command right into a heat, home mom determine to seven youngsters. It’s an inconceivable job, particularly when Julie Andrews is correct there, however we see her attempt anyway. And solely as soon as does she let her masks slip.

And it’s with Max. Uncle Max, who’s nobody’s brother. Uncle Max who has a pencil moustache and works in showbiz within the Thirties. “Inform me all the things,” he urges, once they’re alone. “Come on. Inform me each teensy-weensy, intimate, disgusting element.”

“Effectively, let’s simply say,” the Baroness ultimately confesses. “I’ve a sense I could also be right here on approval.”

“How will you miss?”

“Far too simply.”

He regards her. “If I do know you, darling, and I do – you’ll discover a method.”

A scene from Will and Grace.
‘Brilliant younger girls and their even brighter homosexual buddies have been burning up our screens’: Will and Grace. {Photograph}: Channel 4

There’s a tone right here, one thing that feels fabulous and proper: the unknowable girl turning to somebody who actually needs to know her. And never simply on a floor stage, not simply the good components. He needs, as he says, each teensy-weensy, intimate, disgusting element. All of it provides as much as the identical conclusion: you’re protected. You’re protected to be your self with me.

So right here it was: all the things I used to be focused on, in a movie that everybody has seen, that one way or the other held a dynamic nobody had talked about.

“So that you’re writing about your homosexual greatest good friend? Does he know? Is he OK with it?”

We discuss day by day whereas I’m writing the e book; I ship him chapter by chapter. I maintain asking if he’s OK with it. He says he’s. In reality, he’s greater than OK. As a result of this was the deal, wasn’t it? After we met nearly 15 years in the past it was implicit that our function in each other’s lives was to make life itself extra particular. We have been two youngsters in a small Irish metropolis and no person else was going to make us really feel well-known, if not one another. That’s why we wrote failed TV reveals; why we forged each other as Joan Crawford and Bette Davis; why we named our adventures, on high of dwelling them.

Final April, we went to Denmark collectively, on a whim. Now that we each dwell with our companions, brief journeys overseas are our favorite technique to re-access our unique dynamic. Two silly youngsters, confused and excited by all the things. We discovered ourselves in a tattoo parlour and, in a laughing sweep of hungover hormones, obtained matching True Romance tattoos. the movie. The Bonnie-and-Clyde story in regards to the prostitute and the comic-book nerd who fall in love, steal a suitcase of cocaine, and drive to Mexico with the cash.

The e book, which is now a bestseller, turned out to be my suitcase stuffed with cocaine. And right here’s the kicker: they actually do wish to make a tv present about it. The 19-year-olds in 2009 have been proper, in spite of everything. These two actually had one thing, there.

The Rachel Incident by Caroline O’Donoghue is printed by Little Brown at £16.99. Purchase it at for £14.95

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top